Evidence Criteria1. Does it support the theory? 2. Is it trustworthy? 3. Is it telling new information? 4. Can you explain why it is important?
Everyone thinks that Carlos stole the carrot cake, but he is certain that it was the dog, Buster! Read the evidence and use the evidence criteria to pick the best evidence to prove that it was Buster.
Evidence choice 3
Evidence choice 1
Evidence choice 2
buster went to the vet this morning and the vet report said he seemed sick.
Mom said: "I saw the cake in the fridge before bed"
Carlos says: "Buster always wants whatever we are eating."
Dad sent a text to his friend: "i think i left the fridge door open last night..."
Security camera shows no one else was in the house between 10pm-7am.
Dog nose prints on the fridge door
Frosting smears found in busters bed
Next door neighbor says the party was loud
Defend Carlos!
Ariel Emby-Goodwine
Created on November 4, 2025
Start designing with a free template
Discover more than 1500 professional designs like these:
View
Advent Calendar
View
Tree of Wishes
View
Witchcraft vertical Infographic
View
Halloween Horizontal Infographic
View
Halloween Infographic
View
Halloween List 3D
View
Magic and Sorcery List
Explore all templates
Transcript
Evidence Criteria1. Does it support the theory? 2. Is it trustworthy? 3. Is it telling new information? 4. Can you explain why it is important?
Everyone thinks that Carlos stole the carrot cake, but he is certain that it was the dog, Buster! Read the evidence and use the evidence criteria to pick the best evidence to prove that it was Buster.
Evidence choice 3
Evidence choice 1
Evidence choice 2
buster went to the vet this morning and the vet report said he seemed sick.
Mom said: "I saw the cake in the fridge before bed"
Carlos says: "Buster always wants whatever we are eating."
Dad sent a text to his friend: "i think i left the fridge door open last night..."
Security camera shows no one else was in the house between 10pm-7am.
Dog nose prints on the fridge door
Frosting smears found in busters bed
Next door neighbor says the party was loud