The merchant of Venice
JUSTICE AND MERCY
De Virgilis, Pininfarina, Guglielmino, Soria, Fraternali.
ROLES
03. Observer of the present: Giulia
05. Moderator: Elisa
01. Creative: Gloria
04.Analyst/Connector: Soria
02.Researcher: Federica
BASIS OF THE PAST
Justice and Mercy in The Merchant of Venice
• Shylock vs. Antonio: Shylock demands strict justice (“pound of flesh”), showing a rigid application of law.
• Portia’s Plea: Portia’s speech argues that mercy benefits all and balances justice, reflecting Renaissance Christian values.
Modern Reflection on Justice and Mercy:
• Legal Systems: Modern laws aim for fairness but allow for mercy, seen in concepts like restorative justice.
• Shakespeare’s Message: Justice without compassion leads to cruelty; mercy acknowledges human flaws and prevents harsh outcomes.
COMPARISONS TO THE PAST
observer
Contrast of Justice and Mercy: These themes are often in opposition, as seen in The Merchant of Venice by Shakespeare. • Justice: Focuses on accountability and appropriate punishment, helping victims find closure. • Mercy: Centers on compassion and second chances, allowing for change and growth. • Modern Perspective: Society today emphasizes forgiveness and understanding more than punishment. • Balancing Both: The challenge is creating a system that holds people accountable while also supporting their rehabilitation. • Conclusion: A better society requires dialogue and collaboration to integrate both justice and mercy..
COMPARISONS TO THE PRESENT
1. Mercy: Then vs. Now • Shakespeare’s Time: Mercy tied to Christian forgiveness; Shylock seen as unmerciful. • Modern View: Mercy as a universal value; Shylock viewed sympathetically. • Main Differences: Religious vs. human mercy; Shylock as villain vs. victim. 2. Love: Then vs. Now • Shakespeare’s Time: Love linked to wealth and male friendship. • Modern View: Love is emotional; Antonio’s feelings seen as possibly romantic; Portia’s independence emphasized. • Main Differences: Financial motives vs. emotional connection. 3. Money: Then vs. Now • Shakespeare’s Time: Focus on contracts and stereotypes about Jews. • Modern View: Money represents power and inequality. • Main Differences: Contract-based vs. critique of capitalism.D
https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=g_CaPgFTs7U
Thank youfor your attention
Tesi Istruzione Superiore Equilibrio
Gloria Guglielmino
Created on October 18, 2024
Start designing with a free template
Discover more than 1500 professional designs like these:
View
Audio tutorial
View
Pechakucha Presentation
View
Desktop Workspace
View
Decades Presentation
View
Psychology Presentation
View
Medical Dna Presentation
View
Geometric Project Presentation
Explore all templates
Transcript
The merchant of Venice
JUSTICE AND MERCY
De Virgilis, Pininfarina, Guglielmino, Soria, Fraternali.
ROLES
03. Observer of the present: Giulia
05. Moderator: Elisa
01. Creative: Gloria
04.Analyst/Connector: Soria
02.Researcher: Federica
BASIS OF THE PAST
Justice and Mercy in The Merchant of Venice • Shylock vs. Antonio: Shylock demands strict justice (“pound of flesh”), showing a rigid application of law. • Portia’s Plea: Portia’s speech argues that mercy benefits all and balances justice, reflecting Renaissance Christian values. Modern Reflection on Justice and Mercy: • Legal Systems: Modern laws aim for fairness but allow for mercy, seen in concepts like restorative justice. • Shakespeare’s Message: Justice without compassion leads to cruelty; mercy acknowledges human flaws and prevents harsh outcomes.
COMPARISONS TO THE PAST
observer
Contrast of Justice and Mercy: These themes are often in opposition, as seen in The Merchant of Venice by Shakespeare. • Justice: Focuses on accountability and appropriate punishment, helping victims find closure. • Mercy: Centers on compassion and second chances, allowing for change and growth. • Modern Perspective: Society today emphasizes forgiveness and understanding more than punishment. • Balancing Both: The challenge is creating a system that holds people accountable while also supporting their rehabilitation. • Conclusion: A better society requires dialogue and collaboration to integrate both justice and mercy..
COMPARISONS TO THE PRESENT
1. Mercy: Then vs. Now • Shakespeare’s Time: Mercy tied to Christian forgiveness; Shylock seen as unmerciful. • Modern View: Mercy as a universal value; Shylock viewed sympathetically. • Main Differences: Religious vs. human mercy; Shylock as villain vs. victim. 2. Love: Then vs. Now • Shakespeare’s Time: Love linked to wealth and male friendship. • Modern View: Love is emotional; Antonio’s feelings seen as possibly romantic; Portia’s independence emphasized. • Main Differences: Financial motives vs. emotional connection. 3. Money: Then vs. Now • Shakespeare’s Time: Focus on contracts and stereotypes about Jews. • Modern View: Money represents power and inequality. • Main Differences: Contract-based vs. critique of capitalism.D
https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=g_CaPgFTs7U
Thank youfor your attention